Two suppliers quote 15W-40 at different prices and the cheaper one loses. It happens because the comparison was made on the FOB number, and the FOB number excludes almost everything the buyer will pay. Landed cost is the only figure that can be compared across suppliers, Incoterms and pack sizes, and it is calculated per liter in the destination warehouse, not per drum on the quay.
The arithmetic is not complicated. The discipline is in collecting every line, converting packs to cubic meters, and refusing to compare two numbers that were built on different terms.
| Cost line | Basis | Common mistake |
|---|---|---|
| Goods | FOB or EXW price per pack | Using a price that excludes the supplier’s inland leg to the port |
| Ocean freight | Per container or per cubic meter | Assuming a drum container and a bottle container cost the same |
| Insurance | Around 0.3 to 0.5 percent of CIF | Leaving it out because it looks small |
| Customs duty | CIF value times the tariff rate | Applying the rate to FOB, or guessing the tariff line |
| VAT or GST | CIF plus duty, at the local rate | Treating recoverable VAT as a permanent cost, or ignoring the cash timing |
| Port and terminal charges | THC, documents, release fees | Assuming the freight quote covers the destination port |
| Clearance and broker | Per shipment, plus extras | Forgetting inspection or scanning fees |
| Inland haulage | Per container to the warehouse | Quoting to the port and calling it delivered |
| Finance and bank charges | LC fees, transfer costs, 1 to 2 percent | Ignoring the cost of money between deposit and sale |
| Inspection | Per shipment or per lot | Skipping it, then paying for a rejected batch |
Duty and freight dominate, and together the lines routinely add 25 to 40 percent to the FOB number. What a pre-shipment inspection should cover is set out in quality inspection for importers.
Take a 20-foot container loaded with 80 drums of 200 liters, so 16,000 liters. FOB price is 1.90 US dollars per liter, or 30,400 dollars. Ocean freight is 2,600 dollars and insurance is 0.4 percent of the goods plus freight, or 132 dollars, which puts CIF at 33,132 dollars. Duty at 10 percent adds 3,313 dollars. VAT at 18 percent on the duty-paid value adds 6,560 dollars, recoverable but paid upfront.
- Port, terminal and document charges: 850 dollars.
- Clearance and broker: 400 dollars.
- Inland haulage to the warehouse: 700 dollars.
- Bank and LC charges at 1.2 percent of goods: 365 dollars.
- Pre-shipment inspection: 350 dollars.
Adding the non-recoverable lines gives 39,110 dollars, or 2.44 dollars per liter. Counting the VAT cash as part of the working capital requirement gives 45,670 dollars, or 2.85 dollars per liter. The gap between 1.90 and 2.44 is the number the buyer actually negotiates against, and it explains why a 5 percent discount on FOB is worth less than a 3 percent freight saving. Comparing two suppliers on this basis is covered in finding reliable bulk suppliers.
Lubricant density sits around 0.85 to 0.90 kilograms per liter, so a 200-liter drum weighs about 175 kilograms gross with the steel. A 20-foot container is limited by both cubic capacity and payload, and drums and bottles use those limits very differently.
- A 200-liter drum occupies roughly 0.23 cubic meters. Floor-loaded, a 20-foot container takes about 80 drums; palletised, the count drops.
- A pallet of 1-liter bottles in cartons uses far more cubic space per liter, so the same container carries fewer liters and the freight per liter rises.
- Pails stack efficiently and sit between the two, which is why 20-liter pails are the default for mixed orders.
Most comparisons fail on one of four errors. Mixing Incoterms, so an FOB quote is read against a CIF quote. Ignoring destination charges, because the freight quote stops at the port. Using weight instead of volume, which is how a bottle order gets planned as a drum order. Forgetting the cost of money, which matters most on 30/70 terms with a two-month transit.
- Normalise every quote to the same Incoterm before comparing, and state which one in the model.
- Convert every pack to liters and cubic meters, and price the freight on the real volume.
- Apply duty to CIF, not FOB, and confirm the tariff line with a broker rather than a search result.
- Keep VAT in the cash-flow line even when it is recoverable, because the refund arrives after the payment.
If-then: if two quotes are on different Incoterms, then convert both to CIF at the same port before reading the numbers. If the order is bottle-heavy, then price freight on cubic volume and expect a higher cost per liter than the drum quote. If VAT is recoverable, then keep it out of the margin but inside the cash plan. If the tariff line is uncertain, then model two rates and price so the higher one still works.
Send the FOB price, the pack mix and the destination port, and we will return a landed cost per liter with every line visible, so the next quotation can be compared on the same basis.
Should landed cost include VAT?
Keep two figures. One excludes recoverable VAT for margin analysis, and one includes it for cash planning. Mixing them produces a margin that looks worse than it is, or a cash gap nobody planned for.
Why is freight per liter higher for bottles?
Bottles and cartons use far more cubic space per liter than drums. A container carries fewer liters, so the fixed freight is spread over a smaller volume.
How much does landed cost usually add to FOB?
For drum shipments, 25 to 40 percent is a realistic band once freight, duty, port charges, inland haulage and finance are counted. Bottle-heavy orders can run higher.
